top of page

Is it Sue, or is it you? How to tell your inner critic from your inner knowing.

11 minutes ago
5 min read
Video by Lindsey Elliott Coach Can't Turn Your Mind Off

Earlier this month I ran the first Meet Sue Monthly. It's a free session on the first Wednesday of every month at 5pm. I share a topic, then we open it up for questions, coaching and a bit of honest sharing.


This first one was about Sue herself: the voice in your head, what she's up to, and how to stop mistaking her for who you are. You can watch the whole session above. If you'd rather read, here are the main points.


Who is Sue?

Sue is the name I give to the conditioned, second-guessing voice in your head. She isn't only the inner critic. Most of us can spot the critic by now. Sue is sneakier than that. She can sound responsible and sensible. She can sound a lot like common sense.


She's a metaphor, not a psychological model. And no, she isn't a woman living in your head. She's for men too. Giving the voice a name just makes it easier to see it isn't you.


Sue has one job: to keep you safe. She doesn't care whether you're happy. She cares that you survive. Her three drives spell her name.


•       Safety. Worry, people-pleasing, keeping the peace, over-planning, treating a short email or a look on someone's face as a threat.

•       Uncertainty. Turning things over until you feel sure, trying to control how things go, filling in the blanks with stories. She thinks she's a crystal ball.

•       Exposure. Managing how you're seen. Comparison, fear of mistakes, imposter feelings, hiding who you really are so you fit in.


If you want to know which drive is loudest for you, you can take the Meet Sue quiz. A surprising number of people find it's uncertainty.


Why she's so hard to spot

Almost every school of thought, from the Three Principles to mindfulness to Buddhism, points to the same thing. You are not your thinking. Most of us know that in our heads. Living it is harder.


Part of that is how we're raised. We're taught early on that the intellect is king. Got a problem? Think about it some more. Weigh up the pros and cons.


Part of it is how we're made. Thought is designed to look real. It comes with its own special effects: feelings in the body, a racing heart, a whole movie playing out. And when we're tired, stressed, unwell or low, Sue gets louder and far more convincing.


When we believe that voice is who we are, it's easy to decide there's something wrong with us. That the anxiety, the overthinking, the indecision means we're broken. It doesn't. It would only mean that if you were your thoughts, and you're not.


Is it Sue, or is it my knowing?

This was the first question in the session, and the one people struggle with most. Even clients I've worked with for over a year still ask it. Here are three clues.


1. You've heard it before. Sue is repetitive and habitual. If it's the same worry, the same criticism or the same argument going round for days, that's her. If there's nothing new in it, you can safely turn away.


2. It feels grippy. When you're caught up in Sue, there's tension somewhere. A tight chest, a heavy feeling, a sense of being wound up. Your knowing feels different. It won't always feel good. Knowing you need to end something might feel sad. But it feels right, and it doesn't come with that churned-up, painful feeling. That grippy feeling isn't telling you the story is true. It's telling you you're lost in it.


3. It drops in. Your knowing tends to turn up when you're not thinking about the thing. In the shower, in the garden, walking the dog. It often comes as a complete sentence, and you're halfway to doing it before you've thought it through.


This doesn't mean never using your mind. If you're building a car or working out a tricky job, your intellect is brilliant. We just tend to use it for the wrong task. It's not built to steer your life.


What it looks like in real life

"I know I want to do this." One woman in the group wanted to start something new for herself. It meant an early alarm, and that would affect her husband. Within minutes Sue was batting her between two options: either he's upset or I'm upset. Am I being selfish? Am I rocking the boat?


Underneath all of that was one clear line: "I know I want to do this." That's her knowing. Full stop. The rest is Sue trying to keep things familiar, because familiar feels safe.


Notice too that Sue never tells you the good things that might happen if you change, only the doom. That's your clue. So you hold on to the bit you know, put the rest on the back burner, and let a way through turn up. It usually does.


When your body says it's true. Another woman was dreading a workshop the next day. Being seen has felt unsafe for her for a long time. Her body was tense, and her mind was busy writing excuses. She could see it was Sue, but it still felt very real.


I shared what happened when one of my dogs was hit by a car. He survived, but the first time I walked my other dog afterwards, I gripped the lead the whole way round the block. My heart was pounding, I came home and cried. The next walk was tense, but I didn't cry. I kept going. Now the accident passes through my mind like a little cloud.


My nervous system was firing, but I knew I was safe. The fear wasn't predicting anything, it was old conditioning playing out. Uncomfortable, yes but safe and temporary. The stronger the feeling, the more lost in thought we are.


Watching it unfold. A man in the group said that seeing this had changed how he handles difficult conversations. He used to put them off, worried about how they'd go. Now he just says what he needs to and watches what happens. The outcomes are nothing like what his mind predicted. And when they're not great, he can handle them.


The mind is so rarely right about how people will respond. We can never be inside someone else's experience. So we go with what we know, say it calmly, kindly and fairly, and see what happens.


Sue isn't going anywhere

The voice doesn't go away. Mine hasn't and I wouldn't want it to, because no thoughts at all would mean I was dead. What changes is your relationship with her. She quietens, and she stops getting in the way of your life.


Every time you notice, "Oh, that's just Sue," you're back in your awareness. You're back in your inner knowing, which is far more powerful than your mind will ever be. You'll get caught up again. Then you'll notice again. That's how it works. And if you feel like you're not getting it, don't beat yourself up. That's just another of Sue's tricks.


There's nothing wrong with you. There never was.


Come to the next one

The next Meet Sue Monthly is on Wednesday 2 December at 5pm. We'll be looking at Sue and other people, ahead of Christmas and all the social pressure that comes with it. It's free and you'd be very welcome. Join here.


Lindsey

Recent Posts

See All

Comments


bottom of page