top of page

The "Good Person" Trap

6 days ago
4 min read
Video by Lindsey Elliott Coach, Am I a "Good Person?"

Have you ever caught yourself asking: "Am I actually a good person?"


Maybe it happens right after you say "no" to a request, choose to spend an evening alone instead of helping someone out, or set a firm boundary with a family member or friend. Almost instantly, an internal trial begins in your mind, weighing your actions against a set of invisible standards.


In my coaching sessions with women in midlife, this exact question has been surfacing remarkably often. And when we look closely, two truths become crystal clear:


  1. Every single woman asking this is already a kind, deeply caring person.

  2. They have gotten completely lost in "Sue."


If you're tired of measuring your worth by how much you give or sacrifice, let’s pull back the curtain on where this question really comes from, and why it’s time to drop it for good.


Who is "Sue" and Why Is She Judging You?

If you're new to my work, Sue is the name I give to the conditioned, psychological ego-mind in our heads. She is the collection of habits, beliefs, protective drives, and conditioned thought patterns that attempt to dictate how we live our lives.


When Sue asks whether you’re a "good person," she isn't interested in genuine morality. She is driven by her exposure drive, an ancient evolutionary mechanism that fears disapproval. To Sue, if other people think you are a "bad person," it means you risk being rejected or "chucked out of the tribe."


To keep you safe, Sue insists on a rigid rule: Good people always put everybody else first.

In Western culture, women are heavily conditioned to accept this belief as fact. But self-sacrifice isn't a fundamental truth, it’s just a thought-created belief perpetuated by Sue.


Failing Expectations Does Not Make You a Bad Person

Most of the anxiety around being a "good person" boils down to not meeting other people's expectations.


Whether it's how you show up for friends, how much care you offer aging parents, how you manage your career, or simply how much time you give away, there’s a persistent misunderstanding that failing to meet someone else’s standards equals being a "bad person."


Here is the truth to remember:

Just because you do not want (or are unable) to meet someone else's expectations of you, it does NOT mean you are not a good person.


It simply means you have your own capacity, boundaries, and life to live.


Remember: Other People Have a "Sue" Too!

When someone expects you to behave in a specific way, that expectation isn't an objective truth. It was created by the Sue in their head! Everyone has an internal voice that wants others to act a certain way so they can feel comfortable and secure.


When you disappoint someone, you are usually just failing to comply with their Sue's made-up rules. That belongs entirely to them, not you.


The Subjectivity of "Good" vs. "Bad"

Across our world of 8 billion people, there is no single, universally agreed-upon definition of what makes a "good person."


What we view as "good" or "bad" is almost entirely shaped by thousands of years of cultural, religious, societal, and familial conditioning. It lives entirely in human thought and perspective, not in the objective fabric of reality.


Even when we look at major political figures or cultural debates, one section of society can view a person as an absolute hero, while another views them as entirely wrong. It all depends on the thought filter you are looking through.


If the definition of a "good person" changes depending on where you live, what era you're in, or which culture you grew up in, why waste your precious energy trying to measure up to it?


What's Really Underneath: The Question of Worthiness

If we dig beneath the surface of "Am I a good person?", the deeper question people are really asking is:


"How do I know that I am worthy? How do I know that I am enough?"


We attempt to use our helpfulness, self-sacrifice, and productivity as a yardstick to measure our value. But your worth has nothing to do with anything outside of you.


If an illness or life change meant you couldn't help a single person tomorrow, would you cease to be a worthy human being? Of course not.


Your worth is not something you earn through people-pleasing; it is an innate quality of the awareness that you fundamentally are. In pure awareness, there is no trial, no grading system, and no question of "enoughness." You simply are.


Ready to Drop the Weight of Approval-Seeking?

The next time Sue tries to drag you into a court case over whether you're a "good person," pause, take a breath, and recognise her protective drive at play. You don't have to engage in the trial.


If you’d like to explore how to step out of Sue’s chatter and navigate midlife with freedom, clarity, and peace of mind, feel free to explore my 1:1 coaching programs or reach out for a consultation.

 

Recent Posts

See All

Comments


bottom of page